Let me preface this with saying Ive tried most of the mileage logging apps in the Store. Some are too basic, some are too wieldy (too many options), making it a pain to log trips. Im an airline pilot who moonlights as a real estate agent, so Im very familiar with logging hours and/or miles! After MUCH research, I settled on this app. Its not there yet, but with a few relatively-minor enhancements, it could be about as good as it gets. Heres my feedback:
Hi, I just purchased your app and like it so far. Dont love it because it takes a long time for me to enter my trips (Im switching over from a great Palm app, MileageX). However, with a few seemingly minor changes (Im a web developer myself), this could be hands-down the best Mileage app in the Store:
1. I hate having to scroll the wheels to enter start/end mileage. Its easy when I already have the beginning mileage input (since ending mileage is usually somewhat close), but its a ROYAL PAIN to do when Im trying to enter all my 2009 trips en masse (and from different vehicles, hence different start mileages). Maybe this program just isnt capable of mass-entry. It would be MUCH simpler and easier to use if I could type the mileage in with the numeric keyboard. I could then do in 4 seconds what it takes me 20 seconds to do with your current system.
2. Speaking of mileage entry, you have too many digits! I think 6 digits is enough for 99.5% of the worlds population. Only professional truckers are every even capable of putting that many miles on a vehicle, but their odometers only have 6 digits!! 7 digits just makes data entry more difficult, as the numbers are smaller. Ditch the unnecessary 7th digit and this will be immediately improved.
3. Add an option for turning the time on/off. The date function is essential, but how many of us actually track times? Its not required by the IRS, and only DOT requires times to be logged (i.e. professional truckers). Im an airline pilot and am familiar with these regulations, but I think the time just clutters an otherwise clean interface. It would be great to add a setting to disable times, as I believe most folks using your program dont need the feature. Plus, most trucking companies have proprietary hour-tracking systems, as required by DOT, so they wont be relying on FYI for official documentation.
4. This might be a little more difficult for you, but the date entry for new trips is also a bit cumbersome and un-user-friendly for entering trips en masse. I know why you lumped the month and day together in the date scroll wheel, and that is fine for entering trips from the last several days. However, try entering all your trips from 2009!! Talk about a scroll-hungry app! If I have to enter a trip from April 2009, it takes 17 seconds of scrolling just to get to the date. Not very user-friendly! Plus, you cant even see that youve entered that trip for 2009 (vs 2010) until you switch screens. A better solution would be to split the day/month/year into separate scroll wheels, which would allow me to enter a trip from April 2009 in 5 seconds vs 17 seconds as it currently requires.
5. Could you please add an option to save recurring trip names. For example, I like to title my trips by my clients name (i.e. "Smith"), but I dont want to necessarily save it as a destination, because Im driving them around town to different locations (versus going to the same address all the time). It would save time over having to type their name every time into the trip name header. The Palm program, MileageX had this, and it was very helpful...
Hopefully you see all my comments as constructive criticism. Im trying to help make your app the best and simplest mileage logger in the store, which I believe it could be with the above-mentioned changes!